New Ulm athletes who were selected to Tomahawk and South Central All-Conference teams for 2011-12 basketball included:
Tomahawk Conference (basketball)
- New Ulm Cathedral: Brian Nosbush (unanimous) and Ben Wolf.
- Minnesota Valley: Nate Siemers. Cole Wersal, honorable mention.
South Central Hockey
- NU/NUC/MVL/SE/SESM/S Boys: Brody Peterson, Dylan Schreckenberg, Jeff Banel, Tim Karen. Connor Stark, honorable mention. Girls: Brook Schugel, Lexie Weiss, Erika Ries, Kali Denn. Brittany Denn, honorable mention.
South Central Basketball (Boys): Andy Hawkins. Girls: Kelsy Kannegiesser.